BTC—ETH—SOL—XRP—BNB—ADA—DOGE—TRX—LINK—AVAX—DOT—LTC—
Live

Judge acquits brothers in $25 million Ethereum MEV fraud case

A Manhattan judge acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of fraud over a $25 million Ethereum trading-bot exploit, ruling prosecutors never proved a lie. The case tested whether using public blockchain code against other traders is a crime.

By Himanshu Sakre

Published · 6 min read

A federal judge in Manhattan acquitted two brothers accused of stealing $25 million from Ethereum trading bots. The decision, reported on November 16, clears Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of fraud and money laundering charges and asks whether exploiting public blockchain code is a crime.

U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke granted the brothers' motion for acquittal, according to The Block, which reported the ruling. She found that prosecutors never proved the pair made a material false statement, the fact at the core of a wire fraud charge. The money laundering count rested on the same theory. It fell with it.

What the brothers were accused of doing

Prosecutors charged the pair in May 2024. The Justice Department said the two, both trained at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, planned a scheme for months and drained about $25 million in roughly 12 seconds in April 2023. They set up 16 Ethereum validators and went after three traders who ran automated bots, the indictment said. It was the first criminal case built around this kind of exploit.

The method sits inside a practice called maximal extractable value, or MEV. MEV is the profit that validators and traders can pull from the order in which transactions land on a blockchain. Bots race to spot pending trades and slot their own around them, pennies at a time, millions of times a day. Prosecutors said the brothers fed those bots bait transactions, then rearranged the trades and walked off with the funds. The defense said their software simply beat other people's software at a game everyone was already playing.

Damian Williams, then the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York, said at the time that the scheme "calls the very integrity of the blockchain into question." Each brother faced three counts. Each count carried up to 20 years in prison. The government called the case novel and said nothing like it had been charged before.

To pull it off, the brothers spent about 529.5 ETH, worth roughly $880,000 at the time, to stand up their validators, prosecutors said. They then moved the proceeds through shell companies, a string of private wallets and foreign exchanges to hide the trail, according to the indictment. Weeks of planning. Twelve seconds to act.

Why the judge threw out the case

Clarke's reasoning was narrow and technical, according to The Block's account of the ruling. Wire fraud needs a lie. It needs a material misrepresentation that fools a victim into handing something over. The judge found the government had not shown one. The brothers used the network's own rules against other automated traders, and that, she concluded, was not the same as deceiving them in the way the statute requires.

She pointed to a second gap. The trades did not happen on a regulated market where this conduct is banned by rule. The question before the court, she stressed, was not whether the strategy was improper or unfair. It was whether it broke the specific laws prosecutors had chosen to bring.

This was the government's second try. A first trial ended in a mistrial in November 2025, when a jury deadlocked after weeks of testimony. Jurors sent notes asking the court to define words like "unlawful" and "intentional." During that trial, prosecutors conceded there was no specific law covering blockchain fraud. They were asking a jury to map decades-old fraud statutes onto code most people in the room had never seen.

That first trial showed how hard the line is to draw in front of 12 ordinary people. Prosecutors reached for analogies, comparing the blockchain to a ledger and validators to referees, while the defense argued the brothers had broken no rule the network itself enforced. The jury could not agree. The judge's acquittal has now done what the jurors would not.

What the acquittal means for crypto prosecutions

Timing matters here. Federal enforcement of crypto has already cooled this year, and the Securities and Exchange Commission recently brought its fewest enforcement cases since 1991. The acquittal adds a second lesson for the government: ordinary fraud law is a blunt tool against adversarial on-chain trading.

The defense's core argument was plain. On a public blockchain, everyone plays by code that anyone can read and anyone can run. If the brothers found a sharper move inside those rules, their lawyers said, they outtraded the other bots rather than defrauded them. That idea, often shortened to "code is law," has circled crypto since the 2016 hack of The DAO, when an attacker drained a well-known Ethereum fund by using its contract exactly as written.

There is an irony the case never settled. The bots the brothers drained were not passive savers. They ran so-called sandwich strategies of their own, a practice that earns money by boxing in other users' trades and is itself widely resented on Ethereum. One set of predatory bots beat another. Prosecutors then had to argue that the first crossed a criminal line while the second did not.

Supporters of the defense read the outcome as proof that code is law. If a public network lets you do something, they argue, doing it cannot be theft. That reading goes too far. Clarke did not rule that on-chain exploits are legal. She ruled that these prosecutors did not prove these charges under these statutes. A trial-court decision binds no other judge, and the government can appeal.

Federal prosecutors have had more success with plain theft. The Justice Department moved this month to seize funds tied to a North Korean hack of a major exchange. A stolen private key is easy for a jury to grasp. A trade that followed a network's public rules, and still took $25 million, is not. That gap is the whole story.

What to watch

Prosecutors have not said whether they will appeal. If they do, an appeals court could set a rule that trial judges across the country would have to follow, one way or the other. Until then, the ruling stands as a single judge's reading in a single case.

Builders and traders will watch for how prosecutors frame the next MEV case, if there is one. The likely shift is away from fraud and toward charges that fit the conduct better, or toward clearer theft. For victims of future exploits, the takeaway is cold. A loss on-chain may not become a win in court.

Frequently asked

Were the Peraire-Bueno brothers found guilty?

No. U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of fraud and money laundering charges, reported on November 16, 2026. She ruled that prosecutors never proved the brothers made a material false statement, which a wire fraud charge requires. An earlier trial in November 2025 had ended in a mistrial after the jury deadlocked.

What is an MEV exploit?

MEV stands for maximal extractable value, the profit traders and validators can earn from the order in which transactions are added to a blockchain. Bots compete to spot pending trades and position their own around them. Prosecutors said the brothers manipulated that process to divert about $25 million from other bots in roughly 12 seconds in April 2023.

Does the acquittal make blockchain exploits legal?

No. The ruling found that prosecutors failed to prove fraud under the specific laws they used, not that on-chain exploits are allowed. A trial-court decision does not bind other judges, and prosecutors can appeal. It shows that fraud statutes are a poor fit for adversarial on-chain trading, not that such trading is risk-free or lawful.

Sources, and what is behind them

  1. Peraire-Bueno brothers acquitted of wire fraud in $25 million Ethereum MEV case, The Block (November 16, 2026)Press report
  2. Two Brothers Arrested for Attacking the Ethereum Blockchain and Stealing $25 Million in Cryptocurrency, IRS Criminal Investigation / U.S. Attorney SDNY (May 15, 2024)Press report
  3. Feds Arrest Crypto Bros for 'Attacking Ethereum' With MEV Exploit, Decrypt (May 15, 2024)Press report