BTC—ETH—SOL—XRP—BNB—ADA—DOGE—TRX—LINK—AVAX—DOT—LTC—
Live

Can Bitcoin go to zero? What would actually have to happen

Bitcoin could in theory fall to nothing, like any asset with no company behind it. It has dropped more than 80 percent twice and recovered both times. Here is what a true zero would take, why some economists say its value is already zero, and the losses that are far more common.

By Himanshu Sakre

Published · 7 min read

Yes, Bitcoin can go to zero. Any asset with no company and no promise behind it can, in theory, end up worth nothing. But it has not. Bitcoin has fallen more than 80 percent twice and climbed back both times. This guide covers what a true zero would take, and the losses that happen far more often.

What going to zero really means

Going to zero means one bitcoin reaches nothing and stays there. Not a crash. A lasting end, where the coin trades at zero because no one will pay for it. That is different from a steep fall. Prices have dropped hard many times and still found buyers at the bottom.

There is a reason the question is hard to answer cleanly. Bitcoin has no chief executive, no head office, and no shares. No firm can go bankrupt and mail you a final notice. The network runs on thousands of computers spread across the world. So a zero would not come from one company failing. It would need people everywhere to decide, at roughly the same time, that the coin is worth nothing, and to keep deciding that.

Picture a house that loses half its value in a downturn. The owner is poorer, but the home still stands and can sell again later. A zero is the house burning down with no insurance. One is a painful loss. The other is the end. People who mix up the two tend to panic at the wrong moment.

It has crashed before, and come back

Bitcoin's record is a run of brutal falls. In December 2017 the price reached about $20,000. A year later it traded near $3,200, a drop of roughly 84 percent, according to Cointelegraph. Plenty of people wrote it off. It recovered.

The next cycle hurt more in dollar terms. Bitcoin peaked near $69,000 in November 2021, then fell below $20,000 by June 2022, Cointelegraph reported, after the collapse of the TerraUSD stablecoin set off a wave of forced selling across crypto lenders. The Block put the top-to-bottom decline at 77 percent.

Then came the rebound. On March 5, 2024, Bitcoin broke above its old record of $69,000, 846 days after the previous peak, The Block reported. Spot Bitcoin ETFs approved earlier that year pulled in fresh money and helped drive the move.

Each time, plenty of people called it finished. Each time, it did not stay down. That pattern is not a promise. Past recoveries do not guarantee the next one, and the climbs have taken longer as the price has grown. A deep fall is simply not the same event as a zero.

What makes a sudden zero hard

Several features make an overnight zero unlikely, though none rule it out. Bitcoin has no single point of failure. Shut down one country's miners and the rest keep producing blocks, which is what happened when China forced its mining industry out in 2021. The machines moved to the United States and elsewhere, and the network barely paused.

Supply is the other piece. Only 21 million coins will ever exist, and the rate of new issuance keeps falling on a fixed schedule. Scarcity sets no floor by itself, but it means no one can print more to flood the market. Ownership has also widened. Large asset managers now hold bitcoin inside regulated ETFs, which gives more big institutions a stake in an orderly market rather than a wipeout.

Attacking the network head-on costs a fortune as well. Rewriting Bitcoin's records would take more computing power than most governments could gather, plus the electricity to run it. That price tag keeps a hostile takeover expensive and slow rather than quick and cheap.

None of this is a safety net. These traits slow a fall and spread the risk. They cannot force a single person to keep buying.

Why some economists say the value is already zero

Not everyone frames the danger as a future crash. Some argue the real worth is nothing today. Two European Central Bank officials made that case bluntly in a blog post dated February 22, 2024.

Ulrich Bindseil, the ECB's Director General for Market Infrastructure and Payments, and Jurgen Schaaf, an adviser in the same unit, wrote that "without any cash flow or other returns, the fair value of an asset is zero." Bitcoin pays no dividend and earns no interest, so in their view the price rests only on the hope that a later buyer pays more.

Supporters answer that gold works the same way. A stock pays dividends and a bond pays interest, yet gold does neither and has held value for centuries. Worth, they say, can rest on scarcity and demand alone. Both sides can be partly right. The market price is plainly not zero, while the question of what ought to support that price stays open, and the ECB authors themselves stop short of predicting the price will fall to nothing.

What would actually have to happen

For Bitcoin to hit zero and stay there, demand would have to vanish almost entirely. That is a high bar. A handful of events could push it that way, alone or together, and all of them sit at the edge of what is plausible rather than in any forecast.

One path is a fatal software flaw. If someone found a way to fake coins or spend the same bitcoin twice, trust could break within days. The code is open and watched by a global pool of developers, which has kept such a break from happening in more than 15 years. Watched does not mean invincible.

Another path is a coordinated global ban. Single countries have tried and failed to stamp it out. A true zero would need most large economies to outlaw holding and enforce it at the same time, with no safe market left anywhere. That has never come close to happening.

Slower still is plain replacement. A newer system that does the same job faster and cheaper could pull users away over years. Even then, a gradual bleed is far more likely than a sudden collapse. Each of these is possible. None is underway now.

The risks that are more likely than zero

Most people face a different danger than a global zero. It is a personal one. You can lose everything you own while Bitcoin itself trades fine.

Lose your private keys and the coins are gone for good. There is no reset button. People have lost life-changing sums to a forgotten recovery phrase or a dead hard drive thrown out years ago.

Keep your coins on an exchange and you are trusting that firm to stay solvent. When FTX collapsed in November 2022, customers lost access to their money overnight, NBC News reported. A court later approved a plan to repay them from recovered funds, yet the money sat frozen for years. Holding your own keys avoids that failure. It also moves the whole burden onto you.

Borrowed money adds one more trap. A sharp move can wipe out a position bought on margin in minutes, even if the price bounces an hour later. The broker sells you out to cover the loan, and you get no vote. That can zero out your account while Bitcoin itself barely moves.

Scammers are a bigger threat to most wallets than the market is. Fake support agents, phishing links, and traps that ask you to approve a malicious contract can empty a wallet directly, with no price crash involved. Slow down before you click or sign anything, and check who you are really dealing with.

What to watch

Watch demand, not headlines. The questions that matter are whether people keep using and holding Bitcoin, whether large holders stay put, and whether governments shift from writing rules toward outright bans. Swings of 50 percent or more are normal and say little about a zero.

You can lower your own odds of a personal zero no matter what the market does. Hold your coins in self-custody, keep your recovery phrase offline and backed up in more than one place, skip borrowed money, and never put in cash you need soon. None of that stops a crash. All of it stops the avoidable wipeouts.

A zero stays possible, the same way it is possible for any asset with no cash flow behind it. It has not happened in more than 15 years, through falls that looked final at the time. Treat anyone who swears it can never drop, or that it is certain to, with equal care. Neither of them knows.

Frequently asked

Has Bitcoin ever gone to zero?

No. Bitcoin has never traded at zero in more than 15 years. It has fallen more than 80 percent on several occasions, including a drop to about $3,200 in December 2018 and below $20,000 in 2022, but it climbed back to new record highs after each of those crashes.

Why do some experts say Bitcoin's value is already zero?

Two European Central Bank officials argued in February 2024 that an asset with no cash flow or returns has a fair value of zero. Bitcoin pays no dividend or interest, so its price depends on demand alone. Supporters counter that gold works the same way and has held value for centuries.

What is more likely than Bitcoin going to zero?

Losing your own coins is far more common. A forgotten seed phrase, a failed exchange like FTX in 2022, or a forced sale of a position bought with borrowed money can wipe out your holdings even when Bitcoin itself trades normally. Self-custody and avoiding margin cut those risks.

Sources, and what is behind them

  1. ETF approval for bitcoin – the naked emperor's new clothes, European Central Bank (February 22, 2024)Other
  2. A brief history of bitcoin crashes and bear markets: 2009–2022, CointelegraphPress report
  3. Bitcoin price breaks above previous all-time high of $69,000 after 846 days, The Block (March 5, 2024)Press report
  4. FTX customers may get their money back, but not gains from crypto price increases, NBC NewsPress report